Back to blog
1 min readBy ACWI

STB to Hold Hearing About Rail Competitive Switching

Volume 2, Issue 3 - February 15, 2014 A hearing by the Surface Transportation Board to explore the issues raised by a proposal to allow more railroad competitive switching will be held March 25-26 at STB headquarters in Washington, DC. The National…

Volume 2, Issue 3 - February 15, 2014

A hearing by the Surface Transportation Board to explore the issues raised by a proposal to allow more railroad competitive switching will be held March 25-26 at STB headquarters in Washington, DC.

The National Industrial Transportation League petitioned earlier for the STB to modify its standards and grant captive shippers increased access to competing railroads if there is a working interchange within a reasonable distance (defined as 30 miles by NITL).

The board said it decided to schedule the hearing to deal with issues raised by the numerous comments it has received in response to NITL’s proposal.

The league asserts that its proposal will make the railroads more competitive and save shippers with access to only one line about $900 million annually.

The Association of American Railroads told the STB that Class I railroads could lose revenue up to 80% of their entire annual capital budgets if competitive switching is adopted. AAR says Class I railroads would suffer yearly revenue losses of up to $7.8 billion if the proposal is adopted, an amount that NITL disputes.

The league has informed the STB that its research shows 78% of the 28,000 places throughout the United States with rail service are served by a single major railroad, including 70% of chemical plants. NITL also told the board that for agricultural products, whole regions and in some cases entire states are served by only a single major railroad.

Scheduled to appear at the March hearing are representatives of NITL and AAR, along with individual shipper and individual rail companies, including coal, agricultural firms and both Class I and short-line railroads.

Originally published February 15, 2014 · updated March 24, 2023.

Related reading

Browse all posts →
4 min

ACWI Spotlight: June 2026

WELCOME JUNE! Chris Kane will be attending the Summer Fancy Food Show in New York City at the end of June. We are excited to share two outstanding resumes with the Xchange Board, welcome Jose Larenas as Strategy & Operations Lead, and cover manufacturing renaissance, IWLA's 3PL impact study, cargo theft recovery, and more…

7 min

ACWI Spotlight: May 2026

HELLO MAY! Dear Members, We welcome May with a lot of global uncertainty — the tariffs that were imposed are now in the process of refunding, oil prices are at record highs, and the four-year transportation recession seems to be behind us. Manufacturing is coming back to America, Mexico just passed China as the #1 exporter to the U.S., and our team is positioning members to take advantage of both shifts…

5 min

ACWI Spotlight: April 2026

WELCOME SPRING! Dear Members, I know many of our members are welcoming Spring after a long hard winter. As you are reading this, I am attending the IWLA Conference in San Antonio, Texas. The IWLA is actually 20 years older than us and is the oldest Warehouse…