Back to blog
2 min readBy ACWI

DOT Tests New Accident Rating

The U.S. Department of Transportation is studying how to allow some truck accidents to be reported officially as having been non-preventable. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is conducting a two-year study of how fleets go about listing…

The U.S. Department of Transportation is studying how to allow some truck accidents to be reported officially as having been non-preventable.

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is conducting a two-year study of how fleets go about listing accidents on the DOT Safety Measurement System.

It is looking into possible procedures for allowing the filing of information FMCSA can regard as adequate for the non-preventable characterization.

If FMCSA finds a crash was not preventable, it will not be included in the trucker’s Crash Indicator Behavioral Analysis Safety Improvement Category, (BASIC) score.

“Stakeholders have expressed concern that the Crash Indicator BASIC may not identify the highest-risk motor carriers for interventions and that the listing of crashes on the public website, without an indication of preventability, can give an inaccurate impression about the risk posed by the company,” FMCSA observes.

“The data gathered through the demonstration program will allow the agency to better evaluate the utility of making crash preventability determinations,” the agency adds.

Eight categories of accident would be automatically eligible to be reviewed. Among them are accidents where a truck or bus is hit by a driver who is under the influence, driving in the wrong direction, strikes the commercial vehicle in the rear or while the truck or bus was legally stopped or parked.

Other situations include attempts to commit suicide by stepping or driving in front of the truck; an accident that damages the truck after striking an animal in the roadway; where a truck is struck by infrastructure, such as falling trees or rocks; and occasions where a truck is struck by cargo or equipment from another vehicle.

Originally published September 18, 2017 · updated March 22, 2023.

Related reading

Browse all posts →
4 min

ACWI Spotlight: August 2026

Welcome August. July was a great month for the team at ACWI. Chris recaps the August 4 quarterly members call, business development with Jose Larenas and Zach, industry coverage on sibling succession, supply chain volatility, broker liability, robotics, and last-mile growth, plus a Spotlight on Valley Distributing & Storage.

8 min

ACWI Spotlight: July 2026

JULY IS HERE! As we welcome July, our Country is celebrating our 250th Anniversary. We are all lucky to live in the greatest country in the world. We recognize all of our service members who sacrificed so much for our country. ACWI is continuing to celebrate our 115 year anniversary.

7 min

ACWI Spotlight: June 2026

WELCOME JUNE! Chris Kane will be attending the Summer Fancy Food Show in New York City at the end of June. We are excited to share two outstanding resumes with the Xchange Board, welcome Jose Larenas as Strategy & Operations Lead, and cover manufacturing renaissance, IWLA's 3PL impact study, cargo theft recovery, and more…